By Dan Brown
New York: Atria, 2000
572 pages
I am not a fan of Dan Brown. I have read two of his books now, the most famous ones, Angels and Demons and The Da Vinci Code. I am not a great fan of thrillers in general. I can appreciate them, and when there’s nothing else in the house to read, I might pick one up. But mostly, I feel like thrillers are a waste of my time. I’m an ideas man. But thrillers aren’t really about the ideas, they’re about action. They’re about heroes somersaulting past a gauntlet of villains and deadlines to counter whichever foreign conspiracy is trying to overthrow whatever local institution.
Occasionally, however, you will come across a thriller that can tickle both mind and body—a book equally balanced between thrill and idea. A few years ago, when I had heard the hullabaloo made over The Da Vinci Code, I thought that that book might be one of these elusive gems. But it wasn’t. And then several friends suggested that Angels and Demons was even better than the Da Vinci Code, and so I thought I’d give Mr. Brown another try. Again, disappointment.
Any other thriller I would dislike for all the general reasons listed above, but Dan Brown’s thrillers disappoint me on a deeper level. You see, there is one aspect of Brown’s approach that I find particularly offensive as a reader/writer. It’s embodied in the “Author’s Note” at the front of Angels and Demons: "References to all works of art, tombs, tunnels, and architecture in Rome are entirely factual (as are their exact locations). They can still be seen today. The Brotherhood of the Illuminati is also factual."
Most thrillers stay well to the fiction side of the line between fiction and reality—their main purpose, after all, is entertainment, escapism. Writers of thrillers understand that their work takes the reader into a fabricated reality, an other-world in which the reader’s imagination can play. Dan Brown does this same thing. His work is an other-world. But he presents it as the real world. In what amounts to a literary lie, he intentionally blurs the line between fact and fiction to make his work seem connected to reality.
Brown’s work has as much factual validity as reality television. Both are careful constructions. In reality TV, the “characters” are manipulated from the outset, personalities chosen to create conflict, situations manipulated to produce desired outcomes, and finally, careful editing to fabricate tension. All this control, and yet it is presented to us as though it were spontaneous. Brown is giving us the same thing: presenting a story as grounded in fact when this grounding is actually a construct, a fabrication.
I’m not denying the existence of the super-secret organizations, like the Illuminati, that are Brown’s favorite topics. What I am denying is the lie that Brown’s depiction of their practices and existence is simple fact. What Brown gives us is an interpretation of these organizations, a reading of the signs and symbols that somehow exist in our world. The problem is that Brown presents his information as cold, hard truth when in reality all he is giving us is his personal, flawed, imagined interpretation.
Reading Dan Brown is like listening to a known liar. Some of what they say is certainly truth, and a lot of it is BS, but the majority of it is an unknown quantity—could be reality, could be fabrication. Either way, I don’t mind lies so much—I am an author myself, you know—so long as I know they are lies. But when I know that someone is lying to me, and presenting his lies as the truth, that’s when I start to get annoyed.
Tuesday, March 31, 2009
Angels and Demons
Labels:
Angels and Demons,
Antimatter,
Catholic,
CERN,
Dan Brown,
Illuminati,
Rome
Thursday, March 19, 2009
People of the Book
By Geraldine Brooks
New York: Penguin, 2008
372 pages
There’s whole genre of stories dealing with books; books about books, some would call it. For us bibliophiles, these are the tasty, indulgent treats we allow ourselves every so often, sugary bits of literary lore that express perfectly the adventures of the mind while the body rests. There have been a few successful books about books in recent years—Carlos Ruiz Zafón’s The Shadow of the Wind being one of the most notable—and to this cadre we can add Geraldine Brooks’s most recent novel, People of the Book.
One of the great things about writing books about books, and especially when the book you are writing about is particularly old as they almost always are in this genre of literature, is that old books, like old bodies are covered in the marks of existence. Like the scars that accumulate on our human forms as we age, so too do books acquire scars through handling. And, just as many of the marks on our bodies suggest stories, so, too, do the marks on books. Brooks has reconstructed the history of a particularly old and famous book, the Sarajevo Haggadah, by investigating its marks: holes left over from a set of missing clasps, an insect wing, a wine stain, a single white hair, a mysterious illumination.
Despite the breadth of the years, cultures, and geography covered in her work, Brooks’s research is impeccable. She moves adeptly between the mildly globalized world of 1996, to Sarajevo during World War Two, Vienna in 1894, Venice 1690, and Tarragona and Seville in the 15th century, following the Haggadah back to its origins. I will always remember the absurd formality of Viennese phone operators at the beginning of the twentieth century.
At each layer of history, Brooks imagines complex, flawed, and yet noble human beings intervening on behalf of the book despite threats of fascism, imperialism, misogyny, and inquisition. From the Muslim couple who hide the Jewish book and girl in their home during the Nazi occupation of Yugoslavia, to the young slave woman who painted the illuminations of the Haggadah at a time when depiction was deemed heretical. These are not super-humans, these interveners, but are ordinary people, plagued by disease and temptation, ideology and cruelty, who find in the book a reason to transcend themselves.
Books are one of the most important elements that bind us to our history. The lifespan of a book, especially one as finely crafted and cared for as the Sarajevo Haggadah, lasts lifetimes. It is little wonder that the books about books genre resonates with us today. For those of us who have felt some connection with Stephen Dedalus, Huckleberry Finn, or Don Quixote, or with Jesus of Nazareth, the Buddha, or Mohammed, or with our own ancestors through their journals, notes, and diaries, we realize that we have those connections through books.
New York: Penguin, 2008
372 pages
There’s whole genre of stories dealing with books; books about books, some would call it. For us bibliophiles, these are the tasty, indulgent treats we allow ourselves every so often, sugary bits of literary lore that express perfectly the adventures of the mind while the body rests. There have been a few successful books about books in recent years—Carlos Ruiz Zafón’s The Shadow of the Wind being one of the most notable—and to this cadre we can add Geraldine Brooks’s most recent novel, People of the Book.
One of the great things about writing books about books, and especially when the book you are writing about is particularly old as they almost always are in this genre of literature, is that old books, like old bodies are covered in the marks of existence. Like the scars that accumulate on our human forms as we age, so too do books acquire scars through handling. And, just as many of the marks on our bodies suggest stories, so, too, do the marks on books. Brooks has reconstructed the history of a particularly old and famous book, the Sarajevo Haggadah, by investigating its marks: holes left over from a set of missing clasps, an insect wing, a wine stain, a single white hair, a mysterious illumination.
Despite the breadth of the years, cultures, and geography covered in her work, Brooks’s research is impeccable. She moves adeptly between the mildly globalized world of 1996, to Sarajevo during World War Two, Vienna in 1894, Venice 1690, and Tarragona and Seville in the 15th century, following the Haggadah back to its origins. I will always remember the absurd formality of Viennese phone operators at the beginning of the twentieth century.
At each layer of history, Brooks imagines complex, flawed, and yet noble human beings intervening on behalf of the book despite threats of fascism, imperialism, misogyny, and inquisition. From the Muslim couple who hide the Jewish book and girl in their home during the Nazi occupation of Yugoslavia, to the young slave woman who painted the illuminations of the Haggadah at a time when depiction was deemed heretical. These are not super-humans, these interveners, but are ordinary people, plagued by disease and temptation, ideology and cruelty, who find in the book a reason to transcend themselves.
Books are one of the most important elements that bind us to our history. The lifespan of a book, especially one as finely crafted and cared for as the Sarajevo Haggadah, lasts lifetimes. It is little wonder that the books about books genre resonates with us today. For those of us who have felt some connection with Stephen Dedalus, Huckleberry Finn, or Don Quixote, or with Jesus of Nazareth, the Buddha, or Mohammed, or with our own ancestors through their journals, notes, and diaries, we realize that we have those connections through books.
Thursday, February 26, 2009
Chronicle in Stone
By Ismail Kadare
Translated by Arshi Pipa
Edited and Introduction by David Bellos
Edinburgh: Canongate, 2007
301 pages
The small city of Gjirokastër is an odd place, set into the mountains of southern Albania. “It,” Ismail Kadare writes in his 1971 novel, Chronicle in Stone, “was a slanted city…and it defied the laws of architecture and city planning. The top of one house might graze the foundation of another, and it was surely the only place in the world where if you slipped and fell in the street, you might well land on the roof of a house” (1). But the city is more than setting in Kadare’s novel, it is, rather the protagonist, replete with moods, temperaments, and personality in the mind of a young boy during World War Two.
Kadare’s young narrator often thinks of the city as a carapace of stone surrounding the softer flesh if the people that dwell in it. This dichotomy hard and soft, of the persistent and the changeable is a central theme to the book. The city, over a thousand years old, consisting of the very stuff of the mountains that surround it, has always been. This war is just the most recent in a long line of occupations—Albanians, Ottomans, Greeks—but it can hardly kill the city.
The people of the city, however, are all too fragile. It is easy to understand why the young narrator places his hopes in the city’s stability. The machinations and designs of the people around him are broken against the city’s walls and streets. His family and friends are too easily killed.
Chronicle in Stone is a magical homage to Kadare’s hometown, and an excellent read.
Translated by Arshi Pipa
Edited and Introduction by David Bellos
Edinburgh: Canongate, 2007
301 pages
The small city of Gjirokastër is an odd place, set into the mountains of southern Albania. “It,” Ismail Kadare writes in his 1971 novel, Chronicle in Stone, “was a slanted city…and it defied the laws of architecture and city planning. The top of one house might graze the foundation of another, and it was surely the only place in the world where if you slipped and fell in the street, you might well land on the roof of a house” (1). But the city is more than setting in Kadare’s novel, it is, rather the protagonist, replete with moods, temperaments, and personality in the mind of a young boy during World War Two.
Kadare’s young narrator often thinks of the city as a carapace of stone surrounding the softer flesh if the people that dwell in it. This dichotomy hard and soft, of the persistent and the changeable is a central theme to the book. The city, over a thousand years old, consisting of the very stuff of the mountains that surround it, has always been. This war is just the most recent in a long line of occupations—Albanians, Ottomans, Greeks—but it can hardly kill the city.
The people of the city, however, are all too fragile. It is easy to understand why the young narrator places his hopes in the city’s stability. The machinations and designs of the people around him are broken against the city’s walls and streets. His family and friends are too easily killed.
Chronicle in Stone is a magical homage to Kadare’s hometown, and an excellent read.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)